Asphalt shingles · San Antonio, Texas
Are Architectural Asphalt Shingles Worth the Upgrade?
Architectural shingles are built differently from three-tab. This guide explains what sets them apart, what to compare between products, and when the upgrade is worth it for your home.
The short answer
Architectural shingles, also called laminated or dimensional shingles, are built from two or more strips bonded together, which gives a thicker, textured look than single-layer three-tab shingles. [1] Whether the upgrade is worth it depends on the exact product you compare: its wind-resistance rating, whether an impact-resistant option is offered, and the appearance you want. Compare written estimates that name the specific shingle before you decide.
What makes a shingle “architectural”
The difference is in how the shingle is built, not in a different material. Architectural shingles are still asphalt shingles; they are just constructed in more than one layer.
The National Roofing Contractors Association defines a dimensional shingle as an asphalt shingle constructed of two or more strips of material laminated together, and notes it is also called a laminated shingle or architectural shingle. [1] A three-tab shingle, by contrast, is a single flat layer with cutouts that create the look of separate tabs. The extra laminated layer is why architectural shingles are thicker and heavier, and why the surface reads as textured rather than flat.
Because all three names describe the same category, “architectural,” “dimensional,” and “laminate” are used interchangeably by contractors and manufacturers. If you want the precise panel sizes and exposure figures, see the related guide to architectural shingle dimensions.

What to compare between products
Not all architectural shingles are the same, so compare the ratings of the exact product, not the category.
Shingle lines vary in wind resistance, impact rating, and appearance. For example, CertainTeed’s product page for its Landmark architectural shingle lists a dual-layered design, a UL 2218 Class 3 impact rating, and 110 mph wind-resistance coverage terms, with an upgrade to 160 mph available when the maker’s own starter and hip and ridge products are used. [2] Those figures belong to that specific product; a different line will list different numbers. Ask for the data sheet of the shingle actually being quoted so you are comparing like with like.
| Point to compare | Why it matters | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Confirms it is a true laminated shingle, not a printed look. | Is this two or more bonded layers? |
| Wind-resistance rating | Ratings and required details differ by product. | What wind figure is listed, and what install details or matching products does it require? |
| Impact rating | Only some lines carry the higher UL 2218 classes. | Is a Class 4 impact-resistant version offered? |
| Appearance | Color and profile change the look from the street. | Can I see a physical sample of this color? |
| Written scope | Lets you compare bids fairly. | Does the estimate name the exact product and ratings? |
The dimensional look is one visible reason homeowners choose this category. The layered tabs cast shadow lines that shift with the angle of the sun, which is why an architectural roof reads as textured instead of flat.

If you are still deciding between the two types, read the side-by-side guide to 3-tab shingles vs architectural shingles.
Installation and wind performance
A shingle’s rating only holds when it is installed the way the manufacturer specifies.
Shingle makers publish installation instructions that set details such as how many fasteners go in each shingle and where they sit along the nailing strip, and the International Residential Code requires asphalt shingles to carry at least the fasteners those instructions call for. [5] Some wind terms also depend on extra components; the Landmark page, for example, ties its 160 mph upgrade to the maker’s own starter and hip and ridge products. [2] That is why the quality of the installation matters as much as the shingle you pick.
When you review bids, ask the contractor to confirm the fastening pattern they will use and whether it matches the rating you are paying for. For the local replacement process, see the roof replacement service.

Impact rating and insurance
An impact rating describes test performance, and it can affect what you pay for coverage.
Impact-resistant roofing is tested under a recognized standard and rated Class 1 through Class 4. The Texas Department of Insurance says a Class 4 roof covering receives the highest premium credit, and that the discount amount is set by each insurance company on a company-by-company basis. [3] Not every architectural shingle carries a Class 4 rating, so ask which lines in a contractor’s portfolio are tested to that class.
What RRSATX recommends
Before you finalize a product, ask your insurer whether it offers a credit for impact-resistant roofing and what documentation it needs. Then ask your contractor for an estimate that names the exact shingle and its ratings in writing, so the policy terms and the product match.
For how coverage decisions work more generally, a roofer can share technical details with an insurer, but the insurer and your policy decide what is covered. A contractor cannot promise an outcome on your claim.
When the upgrade makes sense
The upgrade is worth most when you plan to keep the home, want the dimensional look, or want an impact-resistant option.
Because labor is a large part of any reroof, the step up from a basic shingle to an architectural line is usually a smaller share of the total than homeowners expect. If you are already replacing the roof, it is a good moment to compare the two categories on construction, ratings, and appearance rather than on headline price alone.
A replacement in San Antonio also needs a permit. The City of San Antonio Development Services says a permit is required for repairing or replacing a roof, and that a homeowner can obtain it or hire a registered Home Improvement Contractor. [4] Factor the permit and the full written scope into your comparison, not just the shingle line. You can start with the asphalt roofing service page when preparing your questions, and read how long shingle roofs tend to last and show their age.
Next steps: what you can do, and what needs a pro
You can do the research and paperwork from the ground; leave the roof itself to a roofer.
You can safely:
- Look at your roof from the ground and note the general condition and color.
- Check ceilings and walls indoors for stains, and take photos to share.
- Ask for product data sheets listing wind and impact ratings.
- Ask your insurer about impact-resistant roofing credits and documentation.
- Compare written estimates that name the same shingle product.
Leave to a roofing professional: climbing and walking the roof, measuring, checking the deck, and confirming the fastening pattern for the rating you want. RRSATX offers a free roof inspection with a written estimate before any work. Do not climb on the roof yourself.
Local roofing service
About Affordable Roofing Contractors San Antonio
Affordable Roofing Contractors San Antonio, also known as RRSATX, provides roof inspections, roof repair, roof leak repair, roof replacement, and asphalt, metal, and tile roofing in San Antonio. Our roof inspections and leak inspections are free, with no fee and no obligation, and you get a free written estimate before any work starts. A technician walks the roof during the inspection.
- Phone
- (713) 504-2341
- sales@affordableroofingcontractorssanantonio.com
- Address
- 4324 Monterey St, San Antonio, TX 78237
- Contact
- Request a free roof inspection
Architectural shingles: questions answered
What are architectural shingles?
They are asphalt shingles built from two or more strips laminated together, which creates a thicker, textured product. The NRCA notes the same shingle is also called a dimensional or laminated shingle. [1]
Are architectural, dimensional, and laminated shingles the same thing?
Yes. All three names describe the same category of layered asphalt shingle and are used interchangeably by contractors and manufacturers. [1]
Do architectural shingles come in an impact-resistant version?
Some lines do. Impact-resistant roofing is rated Class 1 through Class 4 under a recognized test standard, and only certain products reach the higher classes, so ask which lines are tested to Class 4. [3]
Will architectural shingles lower my insurance?
They may if the product is impact rated. The Texas Department of Insurance says a Class 4 roof covering receives the highest premium credit, and each company sets its own discount. Confirm the terms with your insurer first. [3]
Do I need a permit to replace my shingle roof in San Antonio?
Yes. The City of San Antonio says a permit is required for repairing or replacing a roof, and a homeowner can obtain it or hire a registered Home Improvement Contractor. [4]
Are architectural shingles worth it over three-tab?
It depends on the product and your plans. Compare the exact lines on construction, wind and impact ratings, appearance, and written scope. The layered build and rating options are the main reasons homeowners choose the upgrade.
Explore the roofing topic
Keep comparing shingles
Comparing shingle options for your home?
Ask RRSATX for a free roof inspection and a written estimate that names the exact shingle product.