GAF or Owens Corning: How Should You Compare Shingle Brands?

GAF vs Owens Corning

Roofing guide · San Antonio, Texas

GAF or Owens Corning: How Should You Compare Shingle Brands?

Two well-known shingle makers. Instead of picking a winner, here’s how to compare the specific products you’re offered.

By RRSATX Roofing TeamUpdated Sources checked

The short answer

GAF and Owens Corning both make asphalt shingles, and the fairest way to compare them is product by product, not brand by brand. Compare the specific lines in your estimates on wind rating, impact rating, the written warranty, colors, and how the roofer installs them. The Texas Department of Insurance recommends shingles tested to ASTM D 3161 Class F or ASTM D 7158 Class H, which is shown on the wrapper. [1] Installation quality matters as much as the brand.

What should you compare?

Ratings, warranty, look, and installer.

Shingle comparison checklist
Factor What to check
Wind rating ASTM D 3161 Class F or ASTM D 7158 Class H on the wrapper [1]
Impact rating Class 1 to 4; Class 4 is highest and may earn an insurance discount [2]
Warranty Read the written terms: what is covered and for how long
Style and color Three-tab or architectural; colors your HOA allows
Installer Installed to the manufacturer’s instructions [1]
Close-up of brown architectural asphalt shingles showing granule texture
Illustrative image: Example of architectural asphalt shingles; compare the specific product line, not just the brand name.

Why compare product lines, not brands?

Each maker sells several lines at different levels.

Each manufacturer offers basic and premium lines, and impact-resistant options. A premium line from one brand may compare better with a premium line from the other than with its own basic line. Ask each roofer for the exact product name, then read that product’s spec sheet and warranty on the manufacturer’s website.

Does the brand affect insurance?

The rating matters, not the name.

TDI says impact-resistant roofing is classified Class 1 to 4, with Class 4 receiving the highest premium credit, and each insurance company sets its own discount. [2] Ask your insurer which products qualify before you choose. Texas law also limits HOAs from banning wind- and hail-resistant shingles that resemble approved shingles. [3]

What RRSATX recommends

Pick two or three specific products with the ratings you want, ask your insurer about discounts, then choose on color and the installer’s warranty.

Next steps: what you can do, and what needs a pro

Compare products, then pick a careful installer.

You can safely:

  • Get exact product names.
  • Read each spec sheet and warranty.
  • Ask your insurer about impact discounts.
  • Check HOA color rules.

Leave to a roofer: installing the product you choose to the manufacturer’s instructions. RRSATX offers a free roof inspection with a photo report and a written estimate.

Local roofing service

About Affordable Roofing Contractors San Antonio

Affordable Roofing Contractors San Antonio, also known as RRSATX, is a father-and-son roofing business owned by Ted. Ted has 40 years of hands-on roofing experience. The company carries $2 million in liability insurance coverage. It offers free roof inspections and leak inspections, with no fee and no obligation, provides a photo report after the inspection, and gives a free written estimate before any work starts. If storm damage is involved, RRSATX can help as your roofer, not your adjuster: it can document damage and prepare an estimate, but it cannot act as a public insurance adjuster or negotiate a claim for you. [4] RRSATX provides a written workmanship warranty; this guide does not state its terms.

Phone
(713) 504-2341
Email
sales@affordableroofingcontractorssanantonio.com
Address
4324 Monterey St, San Antonio, TX 78237
Contact
Request a free roof inspection

GAF vs Owens Corning: questions answered

Which brand is better?

We don’t rank brands here. Compare the specific products’ ratings and warranties.

Do impact-resistant shingles lower insurance?

They may. TDI says each company sets its own discount. [2]

Does the installer affect the warranty?

Manufacturers set installation requirements. Read the warranty terms.

Should I pick architectural or three-tab?

See three-tab vs architectural.

Request a free roof inspection

Call or use the contact form. You get a photo report and a written estimate before any work starts.

Sources and editorial notes

  1. Texas Department of Insurance — Making repairs after a storm Most common Texas residential roof covering is asphalt shingles; choose shingles tested to ASTM D 3161 Class F or ASTM D 7158 Class H (shown on the wrapper); inspect the deck and replace deteriorated decking; underlayment may be felt, synthetic, or self-adhered modified bitumen; staples are not permitted for shingles; shingles only on slopes of 2:12 or greater; install to the manufacturer’s instructions; verify references and insurance; get written warranty terms; avoid door-to-door contractors. Checked November 19, 2026.
  2. Texas Department of Insurance — Roofing discounts Impact-resistant roofing is classified Class 1 to 4; Class 4 receives the highest premium credit; each company sets its own discount. Checked November 19, 2026.
  3. Texas Property Code Chapter 202 (Sections 202.010 and 202.011) A property owners’ association generally may not prohibit or restrict solar energy devices (with listed exceptions), or shingles designed to be wind and hail resistant, more energy efficient, or solar-generating, if they resemble the approved shingles, are of equal or better quality, and match the surrounding aesthetics. Checked November 19, 2026.
  4. Texas Department of Insurance — Roofing and Insurance: Know the Law A contractor doing the work cannot act as a public adjuster on that claim, and cannot waive, rebate, or absorb the deductible; insurers may ask for proof the deductible was paid. Checked November 19, 2026.

Sources checked November 19, 2026. This guide is general information. It does not endorse or rank any manufacturer and does not list prices. Images are illustrative and are not photos of RRSATX projects, customers, or completed jobs. Suggest a correction.